Collectibles and auctions

Auction listing photos: the shot that gets the click, and the shots that prove condition

By the Topit team. Published .

Short answer

Treat the first photo and the rest as two jobs. The first photo is what bidders see in search and on the auction page, so it shows the whole item, centered and clean. The photos after it prove condition: marks, signatures, serial numbers, the back, and every flaw. Research on online auctions finds more photos help most when bidders are unsure about the item.

The first photo gets the click

eBay tells sellers that the first photo appears in search results, so it should be the best shot, with the item centered and fully visible. Listings can have up to 24 photos, ideally 1600 by 1600 pixels, and eBay says not to add text, logos or watermarks, which can keep images out of third-party search results.[1] Its picture policy bans stock photos for used items.[2]

Catawiki says the first image is the main photograph shown on the auction page and is the one that gains attention, so it should show the item from its best angle.[3] For graded trading cards, eBay will fill in the grade and certificate number when a PSA-graded card is the first picture.[4]

The rest of the photos prove condition

Catawiki says bidders review the images in detail before they bid, and pay close attention to hallmarks, stamps, serial numbers, signatures and labels. It asks that wear and damage be shown clearly, and that editing stop at straightening and cropping, with no colour changes.[3]

LiveAuctioneers quotes a bidder: "When there are only 1 or 2 images, I think the auction house is trying to hide something." It also asks for close-ups of imperfections and worn areas, and recommends square images so photos look right on web, mobile and email.[5]

Grading does not settle everything. When Heritage Auctions began showing coins photographed outside their plastic holders, it said that not all coins at the same grade are equal, and that clearer photos let collectors judge eye appeal before they bid.[6]

What auction research found

Gregory Lewis's study of eBay Motors, in the American Economic Review, found that what sellers disclose on the auction page, photos included, is an important part of the price.[7] His manuscript says photos are particularly important for collectibles.[8] A 2026 study of 31,262 eBay auctions for one phone model found each extra photo went with about a 0.4% higher price, mostly through slightly more bidders, and the link faded for top-rated sellers.[9]

Not every study agrees. An analysis of used-car auctions on eBay found the number of pictures did not raise the price premium.[10] None of these studies measured photo quality or order for collectibles. That evidence does not exist yet, which is a good reason to test on your own site.

What to test

Test the lead image by category: the whole item against the grading label or the signature, for example. Measure clicks from search and the number of unique bidders, not only the hammer price.

Separately, test a required set of proof shots for each category (the back, the base, the marks, every flaw) against simply adding more photos. Watch disputes and returns as well as price, and look at new consignors apart from established ones, since photos seem to matter most where trust is lowest.

How Topit helps auction houses and collectibles marketplaces

Topit Magic Window starts with a free listing photo audit for your own site. You send a few lot or listing URLs. Topit scores up to 12 photos on each listing for lighting, sharpness, framing and clutter, and for clarity when it can read every photo it checked. It shows which listings lead with a weaker photo than one they already have, with the reason for each pick. Nothing on your site changes.

Collectors do not all look for the same first photo: one wants the whole piece, another the signature or the label. The 30-day trial adds one script to your lot pages, and for each visitor Topit picks which of the lot's own photos they see first. Half your visitors keep your current order during the trial, so every pick is measured against it on your own traffic. Topit does not edit or generate photos. It only chooses among the ones you already published.

Topit started as an app that helps people choose their best photos, and the app has analyzed 23,000+ unique photos so far.

Questions

What should the first photo of an auction listing show?

The whole item, centered, on a plain background, with no text or watermark. eBay and Catawiki both say the first photo is the one shown in search or on the auction page.

How many photos should a collectible listing have?

Enough to show every side, every mark and every flaw. eBay allows up to 24. A bidder quoted by LiveAuctioneers said one or two images make them think the seller is hiding something.

Should I edit auction photos?

Only to straighten and crop, by Catawiki's guidance. Changing the colour can misrepresent the item.

Do more photos raise the hammer price?

Sometimes. Studies of eBay auctions found extra photos went with higher prices, mainly by drawing more bidders, but the effect was small or absent in some studies and for top-rated sellers.

Does Topit work on eBay or Catawiki listings?

No. The audit and the trial run on your own auction or marketplace site.

Sources

  1. eBay Seller Center, Take great photos. www.ebay.com/sellercenter/listings/photo-tips
  2. eBay Help, Picture policy. www.ebay.com/help/policies/listing-policies/picture-policy?id=4370
  3. Catawiki Help Centre, Taking photographs: 14 tips for higher returns. www.catawiki.com/en/help/tips-for-successful-selling/taking-photographs-14-tips-for-higher-returns
  4. eBay Help, Adding pictures to your listings. www.ebay.com/help/selling/listings/adding-pictures-listings?id=4148
  5. LiveAuctioneers, A fool-proof checklist for representing your brand and items in your next online auction. www.liveauctioneers.com/pages/a-fool-proof-checklist-for-representing-your-brand-and-items-in-your-next-online-auction/
  6. Heritage Auctions, press release on higher-quality photographs of world and ancient coins, June 12, 2019. coins.ha.com/heritage-auctions-press-releases-and-news/heritage-auctions-launches-new-web-feature-to-offer-higher-quality-photographs-of-world-and-ancient-coins-in-internet-auctions.s?releaseId=3667
  7. Gregory Lewis, "Asymmetric Information, Adverse Selection and Online Disclosure: The Case of eBay Motors," American Economic Review 101(4), June 2011. www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.101.4.1535
  8. Gregory Lewis, the same paper, author's manuscript of January 28, 2011. pdfs.semanticscholar.org/1d2c/979f2c235b59839cf88296b08fbdf21d85a7.pdf
  9. Ahmed Eddhir, "Information Disclosure, Bidder Entry, and Auction Revenues: Evidence from eBay," Eastern Economic Journal 52, 2026. link.springer.com/article/10.1057/s41302-026-00323-1
  10. Thomas Andrews and Cynthia Benzing, "The Determinants of Price in Internet Auctions of Used Cars," Atlantic Economic Journal 35, 2007. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11293-006-9045-7

eBay, Catawiki, LiveAuctioneers, Heritage Auctions and PSA are trademarks of their owners. Topit is not affiliated with them.